You are viewing your 1 free article this month. Login to read more articles.
A number of independent booksellers have threatened a boycott of the paperback edition of Glen David Gold's new novel Sunnyside in response to Sceptre's exclusive deal for Waterstone's to sell the hardback. Others have said they are considering removing the publisher from any recommended lists, or that they will "think twice" about ordering books from Sceptre in future.
Booksellers were mobilised after Sceptre's James Spackman sent an email with information about the exclusive Waterstone's arrangement late last week. Emails were then sent between booksellers, calling for "collective" action to protest against the move.
One bookseller said she would buy a copy of the book from Waterstone's if she was approached by a customer for one, while another said they would source copies from US websites, such as Amazon.com or eBay.
Responding to criticism from indies, Spackman said that "this is the only Waterstone's exclusive we have planned", and "the idea of an independent-exclusive publication in future is far from out of the question, and I'd welcome ideas on that". The publisher has also confirmed it was planning "independent-exclusive signed editions of the paperback" for October, alongside "exclusive POS and extra discount". However, he acknowledged: "These things don't completely make up for no hardback, but I think they demonstrate a willingness to offset the lack of it."
But indies spoken to by The Bookseller still dubbed the move "appalling" and sickening". Stephen Poulter, of Books@Hoddesdon, said he and "three or four" other booksellers were planning to boycott the paperback as part of what was described in an email as a "collective response". "If a customer wants it we will order one, but I'm not stocking it," he said. "I don't see any reason why we should support the paperback if that is what they are doing. It's a very effective way of showing how we feel about it. This is the last thing we need in the current situation." He added:"We will also bear this in mind when we are ordering in future. It will certainly make us think twice."
Alison Lawrence, at The Village Bookshop, said she would not boycott the book, but would not direct people to Waterstone's. "It won't be one I will have in new releases list, I won't be promoting it – but if someone asks for it I'm seriously considering going to Waterstone's to buy it. It really puts any bookshop in a difficult position with a customer to have to say 'I cannot get you that book'." She raised concerns this was "the thin edge of the wedge", adding: "this is not a course of action that will win support from independents. There is still an awful lot we do in terms of recommending books – I would seriously consider not having [Sceptre] on my recommended books list."
Ann Ingleby-Lewis at The Forest Bookshop is also planning not to stock the book. “I think they have shot themselves in the foot – it’s very shortsighted of them.” She said she would consider buying copies from Waterstone’s, but the distance involved – the nearest branch is 25 miles away – meant it was not an option. Offering the paperback three months after the exclusive hardback comes out was “second rate” she added.
Rachel Phipps at the Woodstock Bookshop, added: “I don’t see the point in stocking it – it will have already been out for so long. [Spackman] has offered various possible things, but I’m not interested in that - what I am objecting to is the exclusivity of the deal – you can’t be in favour of one and not the other.”
Foyles c.e.o Sam Husain echoed the feelings of small independents, saying he was "surprised by the move. "I find it disappointing that the same opportunity not been given to us or any other bookseller," he said.
Spackman referred requests for a further interview to Hachette's corporate communications department.