News

Waterstone's cuts 17 head office staff

Waterstone's has made 17 members of staff redundant from its head offices in Brentford and Solihull.

The changes follow a consultation period announced in January and the bulk has taken place in the store operations and commercial teams and their support staff. Scott Coning, buying manager for education, and three regional managers were made redundant. The 17 affected staff have already left the company.

Regions within store operations have now decreased from 21 to 16. Branch managers previously on secondment to regional management roles have returned to their stores. The commercial team is now centring on Waterstones’s range and campaigns after specific roles in these areas were created last year.
 

Fiona Kennedy, head of range and business, continues to be responsible for the business team, along with the newly created range team. Reporting to her will be business manager Simon Wilson, who will continue to manage ongoing publisher terms, and range manager Sarah Clarke.

Toby Bourne takes on the role of head of campaigns and related product. Reporting to Toby is campaign manager Simon Burke, and Chris Gardner and David Plummer as related product buying managers. Range and campaign buyers continue in their existing roles and now report respectively into Sarah Clarke and Simon Burke.

The book chain, owned by the HMV Group, announced a consultation period with staff about a restructure had begun in January, after poor Christmas trading results. The same measure was also undertaken at HMV’s head office. The bookseller also announced 20 store closures in 12 months, with 11 already gone. Staff at those stores also entered into redundancy consultations but it was hoped some would be redeployed to other stores.

Comments: Scroll down for the latest comments and to have your say

By posting on this website you agree to the Bookseller comments policy. Comments go direct to live please be relevant, brief and definitely not abusive. Report any "unsuitable comments by clicking the links"

The only RM redundancy I know about is in Scotland and frankly, I'm surprised she lasted as long as she did because she had far too much humanity and integrity to thrive under the rule of certain individuals. In Ottakar's she was both respected and liked. Waterstone's will be a poorer place without her.

I hate to see anybody lose their jobs in the current climate, although I suspect and believe that the HO staff will find it easier to find new jobs than a regular bookseller and given the performance at times down there it needs a shakeup.

Regarding the individual you mention , I couldn't disagree more strongly regarding that opinion.

'feel every word'?
'withering on the vine' would seem to be more appropriate.

Someones got to the Bookseller and changed the picture - Obviously Dominic feels the need not to have his pic on the page reporting job losses.

Dominic wasn't quoted in the piece, so it didn't make sense to use his photo to illustrate it.

Sass - while everyone is sorry to see the Scottish RM you refer to go, there were a number of other RM redundancies or instances where the RM went back to a store position, all of whom came from the legacy Waterstone's team. Honestly, move on, the Ottakar's integration was five years ago.

We were all surprised she lasted so long Sassoon, you obviously have a wonderful sense of humour......

But obviously not such a good instinct for when to keep my mouth shut.

I worked for the big W till last year. Our then new regional manager 'managed' to lose 80% of his store managers in the first year. Did alarm bells ring at HO? Not that we saw. They probably thought he was clearing out dead wood. He sent messages to thank booksellers about commitment, not about commitment to customer service or quality or bookselling or even making the store a great place, which it was then - it was always 'commitment to waterstones'. First brand loyalty, the rest - apres moi le deluge as they say. Move on according to the market, fine. To think W could compete with Asda or Tesco or even the famous hub with Gardners or Bertrams - mad. Perhaps little w should give away a bag of potaoes with each book? I hear they are now into 'related products' and food. They'll have to teach booksellers to scrape the tomato ketchup and the melted cheese off the books taken to the cafés, read, then left. Surely, that will require yet one more manager at head office. Trebles all round for them then -as usual.

I worked for the big W till last year. Our then new regional manager 'managed' to lose 80% of his store managers in the first year. Did alarm bells ring at HO? Not that we saw. They probably thought he was clearing out dead wood. He sent messages to thank booksellers about commitment, not about commitment to customer service or quality or bookselling or even making the store a great place, which it was then - it was always 'commitment to waterstones'. First brand loyalty, the rest - apres moi le deluge as they say. Move on according to the market, fine. To think W could compete with Asda or Tesco or even the famous hub with Gardners or Bertrams - mad. Perhaps little w should give away a bag of potaoes with each book? I hear they are now into 'related products' and food. They'll have to teach booksellers to scrape the tomato ketchup and the melted cheese off the books taken to the cafés, read, then left. Surely, that will require yet one more manager at head office. Trebles all round for them then -as usual.

great pic of big D. There used to be an ad around showing President Nixon I think and the headline said: would you buy a used car from this man? We can only hope someone will buy a used Waterstones from this man.

Waterstones has been poorly run for years. If it is to survive it needs to scale back to only about 150 branches in affluent areas, with a preference for larger branches.

[Thanks, it's not fair to single out individuals, so edited the comment - Philip Jones]

I presume you mean larger branches because of range, but doesn't it ultimately boil down to rent and catchment area?

150 branches is probably being optimistic.

@Good Trading. No it probably boils dow to whatever the Regional Manager and Area Manager elites want to do to save their skins while everyone else goes down the pan. This is the company who introduced the "perfect rota" and made people redundant and lose hours because ... other companies were doing the same. Will someone hurry up and take it over or close the whole lot down :)

sacking people - whilst spending money on new uniforms that assume our customers are too scared to ask us for help?. devaluing W's bookreading customers isn't the smartest move really is it now.

It's hardly a uniform - it's a top with a bit of branding on it. Surely you've gotten over it by now?

so why don't the (uniforms) tops have the funky new little 'w' with the flowers on them; running two different logos at one time is confusing for the customer.

I do believe swede is referring to our new spangly bright purple tshirts... I for one look forward to looking like a overly keen walking aubergine!

....ok maybe not....

Please do grow up ... People have lost jobs they loved , have young families and are struggling to pay mortgages and again the blog reverts back to T Shirts ! Please please put it in perpective and show a little respect .

Close the whole lot down? That would be a disaster, and a completely unnecessary one. There are plenty of shops that are making a healthy profit and have years left in them. The weakness of Waterstone's lies with the senior management, its relationship with HMV and the fact that there are too many branches that are in the red.

The publishing industry needs Waterstone's. Readers need Waterstone's. However, the chain has lost its way and desperately needs to be managed by someone with vision who will trust the shops to know their local market.

The only RM redundancy I know about is in Scotland and frankly, I'm surprised she lasted as long as she did because she had far too much humanity and integrity to thrive under the rule of certain individuals. In Ottakar's she was both respected and liked. Waterstone's will be a poorer place without her.

We were all surprised she lasted so long Sassoon, you obviously have a wonderful sense of humour......

But obviously not such a good instinct for when to keep my mouth shut.

I hate to see anybody lose their jobs in the current climate, although I suspect and believe that the HO staff will find it easier to find new jobs than a regular bookseller and given the performance at times down there it needs a shakeup.

Regarding the individual you mention , I couldn't disagree more strongly regarding that opinion.

'feel every word'?
'withering on the vine' would seem to be more appropriate.

Someones got to the Bookseller and changed the picture - Obviously Dominic feels the need not to have his pic on the page reporting job losses.

Dominic wasn't quoted in the piece, so it didn't make sense to use his photo to illustrate it.

Sass - while everyone is sorry to see the Scottish RM you refer to go, there were a number of other RM redundancies or instances where the RM went back to a store position, all of whom came from the legacy Waterstone's team. Honestly, move on, the Ottakar's integration was five years ago.

'Honestly, move on, the Ottakar's integration was five years ago.'

You have been assimilated...
A people should know when they are conquered...
etc, etc

Obv. a well handled piece of change management with everybody on side then?! As a customer I've always had the impression that ex-Ottakars staff largely feel it's been downhill ever since the takeover. Worse range, longer time for customer orders, fewer knowledgable staff...

Sadly for Waterstones the people who have mostly 'moved on' are readers. I've been lost to Blackwells, and thank the gods for them.

I worked for the big W till last year. Our then new regional manager 'managed' to lose 80% of his store managers in the first year. Did alarm bells ring at HO? Not that we saw. They probably thought he was clearing out dead wood. He sent messages to thank booksellers about commitment, not about commitment to customer service or quality or bookselling or even making the store a great place, which it was then - it was always 'commitment to waterstones'. First brand loyalty, the rest - apres moi le deluge as they say. Move on according to the market, fine. To think W could compete with Asda or Tesco or even the famous hub with Gardners or Bertrams - mad. Perhaps little w should give away a bag of potaoes with each book? I hear they are now into 'related products' and food. They'll have to teach booksellers to scrape the tomato ketchup and the melted cheese off the books taken to the cafés, read, then left. Surely, that will require yet one more manager at head office. Trebles all round for them then -as usual.

I worked for the big W till last year. Our then new regional manager 'managed' to lose 80% of his store managers in the first year. Did alarm bells ring at HO? Not that we saw. They probably thought he was clearing out dead wood. He sent messages to thank booksellers about commitment, not about commitment to customer service or quality or bookselling or even making the store a great place, which it was then - it was always 'commitment to waterstones'. First brand loyalty, the rest - apres moi le deluge as they say. Move on according to the market, fine. To think W could compete with Asda or Tesco or even the famous hub with Gardners or Bertrams - mad. Perhaps little w should give away a bag of potaoes with each book? I hear they are now into 'related products' and food. They'll have to teach booksellers to scrape the tomato ketchup and the melted cheese off the books taken to the cafés, read, then left. Surely, that will require yet one more manager at head office. Trebles all round for them then -as usual.

great pic of big D. There used to be an ad around showing President Nixon I think and the headline said: would you buy a used car from this man? We can only hope someone will buy a used Waterstones from this man.

Waterstones has been poorly run for years. If it is to survive it needs to scale back to only about 150 branches in affluent areas, with a preference for larger branches.

[Thanks, it's not fair to single out individuals, so edited the comment - Philip Jones]

I presume you mean larger branches because of range, but doesn't it ultimately boil down to rent and catchment area?

150 branches is probably being optimistic.

@Good Trading. No it probably boils dow to whatever the Regional Manager and Area Manager elites want to do to save their skins while everyone else goes down the pan. This is the company who introduced the "perfect rota" and made people redundant and lose hours because ... other companies were doing the same. Will someone hurry up and take it over or close the whole lot down :)

Close the whole lot down? That would be a disaster, and a completely unnecessary one. There are plenty of shops that are making a healthy profit and have years left in them. The weakness of Waterstone's lies with the senior management, its relationship with HMV and the fact that there are too many branches that are in the red.

The publishing industry needs Waterstone's. Readers need Waterstone's. However, the chain has lost its way and desperately needs to be managed by someone with vision who will trust the shops to know their local market.

sacking people - whilst spending money on new uniforms that assume our customers are too scared to ask us for help?. devaluing W's bookreading customers isn't the smartest move really is it now.

It's hardly a uniform - it's a top with a bit of branding on it. Surely you've gotten over it by now?

so why don't the (uniforms) tops have the funky new little 'w' with the flowers on them; running two different logos at one time is confusing for the customer.

I do believe swede is referring to our new spangly bright purple tshirts... I for one look forward to looking like a overly keen walking aubergine!

....ok maybe not....

Please do grow up ... People have lost jobs they loved , have young families and are struggling to pay mortgages and again the blog reverts back to T Shirts ! Please please put it in perpective and show a little respect .

The U.K will be a lesser place without books being sold on the High Street but in time there will only be around 90 Waterstone's stores and these will be in secondary locations. Think of the era of the range holding chain bookshop as a temporary one. New technology and social habits mean the bookshop of the future is likely to be smaller and filled with carefully chosen titles.

In this brave new world booksellers will be less intermediaries and more arbitors of choice but they'll have to get used to a pre-chain indie salary. Customers will have less choice but good value via the Internet and supermarkets .... publishers will have to be choosier and get ready for significant consolidation of the bigger houses and a flight of specialist publishers to exploit fast growing overseas markets.

The story here is of course a sad one of good people losing their jobs but it's really a chapter in a book that is becoming more and more predictable and one that is at risk of being cast aside for something more interesting.

You were hoping for "Big Bang" but this is more "nudge", or just maybe "new old world".

The more I think about it, I actually really do not like my job anymore.
Don't worry, though, because I'm looking for work elsewhere.
However, ten years worth of experience in the book trade really does not translate well to any other bloody occupation.
The comnpany is STILL spending far too much on in-store promotional material, posters, etc. The Hub never delivers on time. Managers still do not walk the shopfloor unless they have something from head office to action.
I feel sorry for people who have lost their jobs but those of us in work should admit that the future is looking grim; we've all had customers browse our books and then tell us they'll get them "online because it is cheaper".
As someone else said, the cheap prices offered online and in supermarkets will result in less choice but the majority of general customers just won't notice.

I've never met an ex-bookseller who has been financially worse off. You're far more employable than you realise, with admin, customer service, marketing and financial skills.

Quite right - I used to think the same thing until I took the plunge and left W after 8 years. Now I earn twice what I did when I was trying to run a W store and garner measly bonuses for returning lots of stock I actually needed. Plus I have twice the energy, expend a thousand times less energy each day at work and no longer wake up wondering what miraculous words of motivation I could find for that day's meeting to propel colleagues through their W career steps (whatever they were really called, I forget) so they could achieve the next pay level which might mean they could afford three halves of lager instead of the usual two on payday, and possibly eventually make it onto the "fast track" for managers. Which was, erm, actually not that fast.

Harry,

Instore POS costs ALOT of money - everywhere - they need to buy it, how dull/cr*p would our stores look without it?!
If your Manager isn't out on the shop floor - they're lazy. I spend all of 5 hours a week in the office, I'm on the shop floor the rest of the time, doing what the booksellers do - to be honest if it really bothers you perhaps you should have a chat about it (they may not even be aware of how it affects you!)

There will always be an element of Penny pinchers, but the majority of people will be happy to pay a bit more if the service is great...it's a bit like tipping in resturants!

But don't worry - your skills can be translated into any other retail enviroment, but, you will still have to work and talk to customers (and sell them stuff0

At last - HO walking the plank instead of just the poor branch staff - for a change. I don't wish to tar all HO members with the same brush - some were very good and competent - but I echo comments here that over the last 10 years, senior W staff have burnt cash on marketing/promotional projects that could have been far better spent, for example on recreating W as something more than just a firm trading blows with the supermarkets. Shop staff/managers were pushed around, ignored, put in straitjackets while the egos abounded above them. Too many W marketing execs/HO staff were getting too used to receiving too much money in their wage slips each month for worrying about Summer Reading POS (lollipops and trains - thanks for that) & forcing shops to devote FOS bays to Michael Schumacher photobooks. As an ex-store management level employee, all I can say is: with more booksellers on the shopfloor earning decent wages we'd have successfully developed in-shop added value in the form of customer service (actually having time to do it PROPERLY), tailored central offers far more to local customers & had time to develop staff).Instead it got paranoid,punitive and to be honest, pretty boring.

I was always taken back by how incredibly incompetent the vast majority of people in HO were, at least the people I came into contact with. Two exceptions being Suzie and Amber who answered many many phone calls with good cheer and helpfulness. Hopefully they didn't get caught in the cull (although, knowing how the company is run, and how they generally seem to lay off the hardest working people, I fear the worst).