News

Jarvis presses Vaizey on library closures

Culture minister Ed Vaizey has repeated his assertion that secretary of state Jeremy Hunt will intervene over library closures "only when all other avenues have been exhausted." 

Vaizey was replying to a written question from shadow culture minister Dan Jarvis, as recorded today by Hansard.

Jarvis first inquired of Hunt, "who in his Department is responsible for identifying and advising him on potential problems with the provision of library services by local authorities, including whether a library authority may be in breach of its statutory duties under the Libraries Act 1964." 

To this, Vaizey issued the reply: "Public library services provided across England are monitored by this Department's officials who engage directly with library authorities. They also monitor correspondence sent to the Department, monitor websites and press articles, and engage in meaningful discussion with organisations that have current information about public library service provision. These include Arts Council England, the Society of Chief Librarians and the Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals."

Jarvis then asked whether the Department for Culture, Media and Sport had set any criteria for intervention in a local library authority, and "whether it is his policy to intervene in local authorities where a substantial programme of library closures is undertaken without (a) an adequate assessment of local needs and (b) a strategic libraries plan."

Vaizey replied: "I endorse the analysis and approach adopted by the inquiry held in 2009 into the proposed closure of libraries by Wirral metropolitan borough council. When authorities consider reorganising library services it is important that they have assessed the local needs of their communities and have prepared a strategic plan for their library services. Library authorities must provide a service which best meets local needs within available resources. Where there is evidence that this may not be happening, dialogue will commence with the local authority concerned. Use of statutory powers, including those regarding intervention, will be exercised on a case by case basis only when all other avenues have been exhausted."

There has been widespread dissatisfaction amongst campaigners at the lack of intervention from Jeremy Hunt over library closures, despite prolific requests for him to do so. The secretary of state has a duty to "superintend" the library service under the 1964 Libraries Act.

Comments: Scroll down for the latest comments and to have your say

By posting on this website you agree to the Bookseller comments policy. Comments go direct to live please be relevant, brief and definitely not abusive. Report any "unsuitable comments by clicking the links"

"when all other avenues have been exhausted"!!! how infuriating! what does it take? what avenues is he talking about? ALL OTHER AVENUES democraticaly available to us WERE exhasuted and yet he sat by whilst we in Glocuestershire, Somerset, Brent and now Surrey had to resort to legal challenges! If we had not won in Gloucestershire our libraries would be closed by now and an unlawful cuts plan that was a "substantive breach of the law" and "bad government" would have been implemented whilst Vaizey sat down and twiddeled his thumbs. We ARE exhausted! say something new Vaizey and stop saying things that are clearly not true!

"If we had not won in Gloucestershire our libraries would be closed by now" << sorry, I meant "if we had not gone to the courts in Gloucestershire" unlawful plans would have been implemented on Vaizey's watch,

Why don't they just admit that they have no intention of intervening in the wholesale destruction of the public library service, in fact it's what they desire! If they try to close your library occupy it and if they try to cut your job then strike, these are the only options open to us!

Even if they do try other channels until they're exhausted, too much damage is done to each library while all of this is happening.

The same old bleat that Hunt/Vaizey have been using for the last two years. "Monitoring on a case by case basis"- translated into plain anglo-saxon "We going to sit on our backsides, wear out the seat of our trousers, drink champagne and do bugger all else".

Is Mr Jarvis satisfied with the answers to his Questions ? He now needs to put some fire into his belly. In politics there is no Geneva Convention nor Geneva Protocol to prohibit a shadow minister challenging inadequacy when that is called for. Mr Vaizey himself knew this in Opposition :-

09 February 2010 :
"Vaizey said it was 'outrageous and offensive' to ..."
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-and-hodge-clash-over-library-fu...

07 February 2010 :
"We can't go on like This !"
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-libraries-we-cant-go.html

03 March 2009
Vaizey Slams Burnham for "ignoring his responsibilities as secretary of state"
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-slams-burnham.html

23 January 2009 :
Vaizey Tables Early Day Motion on Wirral
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-tables-early-day-motion-wirral....

Messrs Vaizey and Hunt must be challenged and called to account by this Opposition until they are shaken or shamed into action. Mr Gove should be challenged, likewise. He knows that that children's literacy is threatened by the ministers' complacency.

Are Mr Jarvis and Harriet Harman "outraged and offended" ? Will they "slam" Mr Hunt for "ignoring his responsibilities as secretary of state" ? Where are the Early Day Motions on Gloucestershire, Somerset, Brent and Surrey ?

Is Mr Jarvis now politely in retreat, having asked these Questions ? A welcome, if belated, start -- but a start only.

Indeed, we "Can't go on like this".

"when all other avenues have been exhausted"!!! how infuriating! what does it take? what avenues is he talking about? ALL OTHER AVENUES democraticaly available to us WERE exhasuted and yet he sat by whilst we in Glocuestershire, Somerset, Brent and now Surrey had to resort to legal challenges! If we had not won in Gloucestershire our libraries would be closed by now and an unlawful cuts plan that was a "substantive breach of the law" and "bad government" would have been implemented whilst Vaizey sat down and twiddeled his thumbs. We ARE exhausted! say something new Vaizey and stop saying things that are clearly not true!

"If we had not won in Gloucestershire our libraries would be closed by now" << sorry, I meant "if we had not gone to the courts in Gloucestershire" unlawful plans would have been implemented on Vaizey's watch,

Why don't they just admit that they have no intention of intervening in the wholesale destruction of the public library service, in fact it's what they desire! If they try to close your library occupy it and if they try to cut your job then strike, these are the only options open to us!

Even if they do try other channels until they're exhausted, too much damage is done to each library while all of this is happening.

The same old bleat that Hunt/Vaizey have been using for the last two years. "Monitoring on a case by case basis"- translated into plain anglo-saxon "We going to sit on our backsides, wear out the seat of our trousers, drink champagne and do bugger all else".

Is Mr Jarvis satisfied with the answers to his Questions ? He now needs to put some fire into his belly. In politics there is no Geneva Convention nor Geneva Protocol to prohibit a shadow minister challenging inadequacy when that is called for. Mr Vaizey himself knew this in Opposition :-

09 February 2010 :
"Vaizey said it was 'outrageous and offensive' to ..."
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-and-hodge-clash-over-library-fu...

07 February 2010 :
"We can't go on like This !"
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-libraries-we-cant-go.html

03 March 2009
Vaizey Slams Burnham for "ignoring his responsibilities as secretary of state"
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-slams-burnham.html

23 January 2009 :
Vaizey Tables Early Day Motion on Wirral
http://www.thebookseller.com/news/vaizey-tables-early-day-motion-wirral....

Messrs Vaizey and Hunt must be challenged and called to account by this Opposition until they are shaken or shamed into action. Mr Gove should be challenged, likewise. He knows that that children's literacy is threatened by the ministers' complacency.

Are Mr Jarvis and Harriet Harman "outraged and offended" ? Will they "slam" Mr Hunt for "ignoring his responsibilities as secretary of state" ? Where are the Early Day Motions on Gloucestershire, Somerset, Brent and Surrey ?

Is Mr Jarvis now politely in retreat, having asked these Questions ? A welcome, if belated, start -- but a start only.

Indeed, we "Can't go on like this".