News

FBF: UK worst country for protecting chains

The UK is the worst country for protecting its high street chains, which are essential for the long-term health of the book trade, the chief executive of Hachette Livre has claimed.

Arnaud Nourry was speaking yesterday (12th October) at a c.e.o. panel at Frankfurt Book Fair. He said diversity in both physical and digital retailers was essential for the publishing industry.

"Without diversity we will not be able to support diversity in creation," he said. "We need to do whatever we can to support bookshops. There needs to be some sort of concentration on the retail side—it’s key for the future of the business and authors. We need to support retailers, particularly the chains."

He said bricks-and-mortar bookshops were still the best way of promoting titles and nothing has had the same effect as books on shelves and tables. The UK was the "worst example" of a publishing industry supporting its bricks-and-mortar retailers, he said. "That’s a situation we must avoid," he added.

Penguin Group c.e.o. John Makinson, who co-owns an independent bookshop in England, said buying books from a shop was an "economically irrational" thing to do.
But he added: "But we need to persuade [customers] to do so, which is doable." Publishers needed to continue ensuring physical books were of a high standard, he said.

"Retailers need to work with us and make improvements in supply chain management so we are not experiencing the same level of returns."

Makinson said he looked "with envy" at countries such as Germany and France, which had fixed pricing, but said there was no possibility of resurrecting the Net Book Agreement in the UK.

Nourry was sanguine about the economic woes sweeping world markets. He said: "We are living in a tough economic environment and this has an impact on the market. But this is just the cycle. Let’s keep our eyes on a little bit further down the road."

Frankfurt Book Fair Daily: Day 2
 

Comments: Scroll down for the latest comments and to have your say

By posting on this website you agree to the Bookseller comments policy. Comments go direct to live please be relevant, brief and definitely not abusive. Report any "unsuitable comments by clicking the links"

Germany and France can do it, but the UK cannot, or will not.

Germany and France have book retail which is surviving, UK is dying.

Germany and France do not have Amazon dominating their book trade.

German and French publishers probably give similar discounts to internet 'sellers' as they do to bricks and mortar retailers.

German and French publishers are clearly more enlightened than their British counterparts, who think about tomorrow and next week rather than the longer view.

And so on and on goes the talk - when will a publisher break ranks and say 'no' to Amazon? Because the German or French publishers clearly can, and do.

As and independent bookseller I am tired of all the excuses for the difficulties facing people like me. A few days ago it was parking and business rates. Today 'supply chain management' is a factor. There is one reason and that is price! When are we all going to be on a level playing field where we can all buy our stock at the same price. If the NBA cannot be brought back then we could at least decide on our mark up.I am effectively subsidising the big guys. I can totally understand why someone would buy Jamie Oliver's latest book at 67% discount on Amazon and have it delivered to their door.As the Old Bookseller said when will a publisher say 'no' to Amazon?

As a customer, I don't agree that buying books from a bookshop is economically irrational - not, that is, of you take account of the other benefits that the bookshop gives which online can't. If you value those them it is perfectly rational.

'...buying books from a shop was an "economically irrational" thing to do'.... he then went on to say, "so here at Penguin we're going to increase bookseller discounts and at the same time reduce those we give to Amazon, just a tad"

So Makinson thinks its irrational to buy a book in a shop....mmmm
wonder what discount his shop enjoy?
as for the supply chain ...they are the ones that take a week or so to deliver...
returns...that will be the supermarkets then

Germany and France can do it, but the UK cannot, or will not.

Germany and France have book retail which is surviving, UK is dying.

Germany and France do not have Amazon dominating their book trade.

German and French publishers probably give similar discounts to internet 'sellers' as they do to bricks and mortar retailers.

German and French publishers are clearly more enlightened than their British counterparts, who think about tomorrow and next week rather than the longer view.

And so on and on goes the talk - when will a publisher break ranks and say 'no' to Amazon? Because the German or French publishers clearly can, and do.

As and independent bookseller I am tired of all the excuses for the difficulties facing people like me. A few days ago it was parking and business rates. Today 'supply chain management' is a factor. There is one reason and that is price! When are we all going to be on a level playing field where we can all buy our stock at the same price. If the NBA cannot be brought back then we could at least decide on our mark up.I am effectively subsidising the big guys. I can totally understand why someone would buy Jamie Oliver's latest book at 67% discount on Amazon and have it delivered to their door.As the Old Bookseller said when will a publisher say 'no' to Amazon?

As a customer, I don't agree that buying books from a bookshop is economically irrational - not, that is, of you take account of the other benefits that the bookshop gives which online can't. If you value those them it is perfectly rational.

So Makinson thinks its irrational to buy a book in a shop....mmmm
wonder what discount his shop enjoy?
as for the supply chain ...they are the ones that take a week or so to deliver...
returns...that will be the supermarkets then

'...buying books from a shop was an "economically irrational" thing to do'.... he then went on to say, "so here at Penguin we're going to increase bookseller discounts and at the same time reduce those we give to Amazon, just a tad"