Blogs

10 points about exclusive deals

Hachette has pulled out of its exclusive arrangement with Waterstone's over Glen David Gold's Sunnyside. What though would be the long-term picture for independent booksellers if these deals became more prevalent.

1) Hodder was expecting the very exclusivity of this deal to generate extra publicity. This would have put independents in a no-win situation of trying to get adverse press coverage whilst trying not to get too much so that the book does extremely well on the back of it.

2) The Independents will no longer be able to satisfy their customers on range and informed bookselling if they are unable to source titles which will have national press coverage.

3) Regular independent customers will be forced to go to Waterstone’s and will make increasingly less effort to frequent their local independent if they do not expect them to have a key title in stock.

4) The long-term future of hardback literary fiction is looking increasingly bleak. With a further weakened independent sector, there will inevitably be fewer shops who will stock these titles.

5) Publishers will have even more trouble getting grass-roots word-of-mouth for any books when fewer independents can read and enthuse about some of their more challenging books.

6) Glen David Gold agreed to this deal. How was this sold to him and how much information was he given?

7) What does this mean for other authors of literary fiction, in particular those who are not as well connected as Gold?

8) What happens when a Booker or Costa short-listed title is not available to the trade as a whole?

9) Other publishers confirm that Waterstone’s is pushing more and more for exclusivity.

10 ) What is Waterstone’s doing that is so special to warrant the special treatment?

Comments: Scroll down for the latest comments and to have your say

By posting on this website you agree to the Bookseller comments policy. Comments go direct to live please be relevant, brief and definitely not abusive. Report any "unsuitable comments by clicking the links"

They would never do a deal like this on a mass market title as it would upset too many of their large customers - supermarkets, WHSmiths etc, they would only consider this for a literary title since there are no other major high street players since Ottakars was subsumed...

If indies are as brilliant when it comes to range and personalised service as they always claim, why are they so worried about one book? Don't they have the imagination to hand-sell and recommend others? Plenty of them didn't bother to discount Harry Potter or even use it as a loss leader, so why the big deal about Gold? Exclusives have been around for a very long time after all.

If you had read the above points carefully you would might notice that in itself this one book would not be a problem, the point surely is that a precedent would have been set which has NOT happened before. Yes there have been exclusives of different editions, everyone has always had the book to sell in another format. It may be Sunnyside today, but in 5 or 10 years time it would be the likes of David Mitchell or even Ian McEwan - I would have thought that even the most industrious independent shop would have problems getting round not having their books to sell.

It was also the wrong book. Sunnyside will be popular in independent bookshops - if they'd made this arrangement on Jordan's next autobiography I doubt there would be as much fuss...

Knowing Hodder of old I am unsuprised by their latest 'testing of the waters'. You are asking all the right questions Isla.

Knowing Hodder of old I am unsuprised by their latest 'testing of the waters'. You are asking all the right questions Isla.

If indies are as brilliant when it comes to range and personalised service as they always claim, why are they so worried about one book? Don't they have the imagination to hand-sell and recommend others? Plenty of them didn't bother to discount Harry Potter or even use it as a loss leader, so why the big deal about Gold? Exclusives have been around for a very long time after all.

If you had read the above points carefully you would might notice that in itself this one book would not be a problem, the point surely is that a precedent would have been set which has NOT happened before. Yes there have been exclusives of different editions, everyone has always had the book to sell in another format. It may be Sunnyside today, but in 5 or 10 years time it would be the likes of David Mitchell or even Ian McEwan - I would have thought that even the most industrious independent shop would have problems getting round not having their books to sell.

It was also the wrong book. Sunnyside will be popular in independent bookshops - if they'd made this arrangement on Jordan's next autobiography I doubt there would be as much fuss...

They would never do a deal like this on a mass market title as it would upset too many of their large customers - supermarkets, WHSmiths etc, they would only consider this for a literary title since there are no other major high street players since Ottakars was subsumed...